Today, as I reflect, it’s April 14th. The
pedagogical moment that, for me, is most prevalent in my mind happened earlier
today, in fact. I was teaching at Everett Middle School in downtown San
Francisco for the day, handling instructional duties for an 8th
grade math class. Everett’s daily schedule is something I hadn’t experienced as
a substitute yet: four periods of approximately 90 minutes, called “Blocks.”
The moment happened during Block 3, in the early afternoon with one more Block
to go before school let out. Reflecting on the experience, now, the day was
unusual for a few reasons. For example, the teacher had informed me in notes
that their Blocks became more and more rowdy: 1 was mellow, 4 was rather
chaotic. Yet, I didn’t really notice any significant difference, which hadn’t
happened to me. (Until today, every teacher I’d worked for was spot on in their
diagnosis.) Each class listened to the instruction I’d been given and followed
it with relative ease. They were in some sort of lull, I guess. Anyway, during
Block 3, something else rather idiosyncratic happened: I was likely a witness
to the hidden conveyance of what I presume was marijuana.
About an hour into the Block, a security guard came inside
the door of the classroom and asked to see a certain student, before ducking
back out into the hall. I stood by the door while the student slowly dragged
themselves up, and while they did, I noticed a very overt—yet, of course,
intentionally covert—passage from hand-to-hand, between them and their table-mate.
They both looked at me immediately after the exchange, and my eyes met the
student who had received whatever it was as
they pocketed it. I was across the room, and as I passed the student who
had been called out, the student who had just handed off whatever it was,
something phenomenal happened. Out of nowhere, several students asked me
questions, one after another, as I passed them. They asked questions that I
could answer quickly, yet while I did so, I would turn my head to look at them.
Each time I would turn my head back to the student waiting, to the student who
had received whatever it was from the student who had been called out to the
hall, I was amazed to see a rapid series of exchanges occurring across the
room, between approximately ten students, to the degree that I lost sight of
the location of whatever it was. Every single student was watching me, and, to
add to the spectacle, various students had chosen this moment to randomly get
up from their seats and wander around, creating partial and fluid obstructions
to my view across the room. By the time I stood by the student I had originally
seen receive whatever it was, I was well aware that I had no accurate idea at
all about where whatever it was had gone. — They’d succeeded.
I was stunned. I was pensive. I was also rather amused. I
mean, let me be clear about what I had witnessed. This occurred an hour into
the Block. By that time, I had a generally coherent impression of the cliques
and associations in current standing among students of the class. By a quite
visible organization, I could see the various friend groups, many of whom had
asked me if they could sit near their fellows while working on the assignment
for the day. I had witnessed instantiations of the antagonisms of between these
groups, to the point of having to sternly rebuke overt insults thrown quietly
across the room. They had friends, and they had
not-really-friends-so-much-as-acquaintances-or-schoolmates. This ephemeral
phenomenon, however, had bluntly and uniformly disregarded the apparent social
topology of the class. Previously distant acquaintances got up to talk to
acquaintances. Antagonistic friend group passed whatever it was to friend
group. It didn’t matter, it seemed, who the student was. I was the authority,
and I was not, by any means, going to be able to apply my regulation. Not of
this entire class had anything to say
about it.
Now, I said at the beginning I presume it was marijuana. This
isn’t just drawn out of thin air. The student who was called out into the hall
came back in, within a few minutes of this, and calmly high-fived the person I
had seen him pass whatever it was off to originally. By this time, of course, I
had realized that I had no way of finding whatever it was without walking out
into the hall and informing the security guard that, oh I don’t know, the whole class could possibly be
withholding something that would get them in trouble, and should be, what,
searched? To be honest, and this may instill some bad thoughts as to my
character, but in a significant sense, I felt defeated. I had no way of
narrowing it down to even a handful of students. I had been duped, and I was
rather deflated. Yet, when the student came back into the classroom, and the
activity of mostly rather quiet conversation while working on the assignment
continued, I pulled up a chair right across from them and their friend, and
spent the next ten minutes monitoring the class from there. I heard such
comments as, “Did you see how close we came?” and “I knew this is going to be the
best birthday ever.” They stared at me, too, while they said this. I said
nothing, and watched them, silently, every so often reminding them softly about
the assignment they had in front of them (neither of them had ever made even
the slightest of efforts in working, let alone writing their name on the
sheet). Later, with only a few minutes left in the Block, and the class itching
to get up and out of the room, I decided to ask, as a way to keep them
distracted and rather attentive, what their favorite part of math is. I then
asked what their favorite part of school is. The student that had been called
out to the hall… they answered, with a full grin on their face, looking across
at the faces of their classmates, “Sales.” — I leave the reader to judge for themselves
both whatever it was that was passed, and the sufficiency of my own address of
the situation. The class left happily, and Block 4 began.
In our reading of Freire, which I readily confess I
repeatedly go back to, the pedagogical revolutionary writes: “It is equally
part of right thinking to reject decidedly any and every form of
discrimination” (41). Freire immediately applies this to “preconceptions of
race, class or sex” (ibid), but, thinking about this episode at Everett, now,
for some reason I can’t help but think of a wider application. From my vantage,
from that single session of Block 3 today, none of the students, none at all,
seemed, what, dangerous, or violent, or ‘bad’. The student that had been called
out to the hall didn’t talk loudly, and listened to my direction and requests.
They didn’t apply themselves to the material, but who am I to demand that they
do, except beyond offering them the chance to learn some math for the 90
minutes we were in class together. They smiled, they were kind to friends and other
classmates, and seemed quite reasonable. And… and to have watched as the entire class, as some sort of organism, worked
in tandem to suppress any chance of remediation. I don’t know. Maybe by
thinking I should’ve done something, then and now, I’m merely an oppressor. I
barely know them, and the large majority of their actions were more than
positive. I… I don’t know… I’m still ambivalent, I guess, but I thought this
merited serious pedagogical reflection, and posting.