Friday, April 22, 2016

Pedagogical Moment 5: Pot and the Pedagogue

     Today, as I reflect, it’s April 14th. The pedagogical moment that, for me, is most prevalent in my mind happened earlier today, in fact. I was teaching at Everett Middle School in downtown San Francisco for the day, handling instructional duties for an 8th grade math class. Everett’s daily schedule is something I hadn’t experienced as a substitute yet: four periods of approximately 90 minutes, called “Blocks.” The moment happened during Block 3, in the early afternoon with one more Block to go before school let out. Reflecting on the experience, now, the day was unusual for a few reasons. For example, the teacher had informed me in notes that their Blocks became more and more rowdy: 1 was mellow, 4 was rather chaotic. Yet, I didn’t really notice any significant difference, which hadn’t happened to me. (Until today, every teacher I’d worked for was spot on in their diagnosis.) Each class listened to the instruction I’d been given and followed it with relative ease. They were in some sort of lull, I guess. Anyway, during Block 3, something else rather idiosyncratic happened: I was likely a witness to the hidden conveyance of what I presume was marijuana.
     About an hour into the Block, a security guard came inside the door of the classroom and asked to see a certain student, before ducking back out into the hall. I stood by the door while the student slowly dragged themselves up, and while they did, I noticed a very overt—yet, of course, intentionally covert—passage from hand-to-hand, between them and their table-mate. They both looked at me immediately after the exchange, and my eyes met the student who had received whatever it was as they pocketed it. I was across the room, and as I passed the student who had been called out, the student who had just handed off whatever it was, something phenomenal happened. Out of nowhere, several students asked me questions, one after another, as I passed them. They asked questions that I could answer quickly, yet while I did so, I would turn my head to look at them. Each time I would turn my head back to the student waiting, to the student who had received whatever it was from the student who had been called out to the hall, I was amazed to see a rapid series of exchanges occurring across the room, between approximately ten students, to the degree that I lost sight of the location of whatever it was. Every single student was watching me, and, to add to the spectacle, various students had chosen this moment to randomly get up from their seats and wander around, creating partial and fluid obstructions to my view across the room. By the time I stood by the student I had originally seen receive whatever it was, I was well aware that I had no accurate idea at all about where whatever it was had gone. — They’d succeeded.
     I was stunned. I was pensive. I was also rather amused. I mean, let me be clear about what I had witnessed. This occurred an hour into the Block. By that time, I had a generally coherent impression of the cliques and associations in current standing among students of the class. By a quite visible organization, I could see the various friend groups, many of whom had asked me if they could sit near their fellows while working on the assignment for the day. I had witnessed instantiations of the antagonisms of between these groups, to the point of having to sternly rebuke overt insults thrown quietly across the room. They had friends, and they had not-really-friends-so-much-as-acquaintances-or-schoolmates. This ephemeral phenomenon, however, had bluntly and uniformly disregarded the apparent social topology of the class. Previously distant acquaintances got up to talk to acquaintances. Antagonistic friend group passed whatever it was to friend group. It didn’t matter, it seemed, who the student was. I was the authority, and I was not, by any means, going to be able to apply my regulation. Not of this entire class had anything to say about it.
     Now, I said at the beginning I presume it was marijuana. This isn’t just drawn out of thin air. The student who was called out into the hall came back in, within a few minutes of this, and calmly high-fived the person I had seen him pass whatever it was off to originally. By this time, of course, I had realized that I had no way of finding whatever it was without walking out into the hall and informing the security guard that, oh I don’t know, the whole class could possibly be withholding something that would get them in trouble, and should be, what, searched? To be honest, and this may instill some bad thoughts as to my character, but in a significant sense, I felt defeated. I had no way of narrowing it down to even a handful of students. I had been duped, and I was rather deflated. Yet, when the student came back into the classroom, and the activity of mostly rather quiet conversation while working on the assignment continued, I pulled up a chair right across from them and their friend, and spent the next ten minutes monitoring the class from there. I heard such comments as, “Did you see how close we came?” and “I knew this is going to be the best birthday ever.” They stared at me, too, while they said this. I said nothing, and watched them, silently, every so often reminding them softly about the assignment they had in front of them (neither of them had ever made even the slightest of efforts in working, let alone writing their name on the sheet). Later, with only a few minutes left in the Block, and the class itching to get up and out of the room, I decided to ask, as a way to keep them distracted and rather attentive, what their favorite part of math is. I then asked what their favorite part of school is. The student that had been called out to the hall… they answered, with a full grin on their face, looking across at the faces of their classmates, “Sales.” — I leave the reader to judge for themselves both whatever it was that was passed, and the sufficiency of my own address of the situation. The class left happily, and Block 4 began.
     In our reading of Freire, which I readily confess I repeatedly go back to, the pedagogical revolutionary writes: “It is equally part of right thinking to reject decidedly any and every form of discrimination” (41). Freire immediately applies this to “preconceptions of race, class or sex” (ibid), but, thinking about this episode at Everett, now, for some reason I can’t help but think of a wider application. From my vantage, from that single session of Block 3 today, none of the students, none at all, seemed, what, dangerous, or violent, or ‘bad’. The student that had been called out to the hall didn’t talk loudly, and listened to my direction and requests. They didn’t apply themselves to the material, but who am I to demand that they do, except beyond offering them the chance to learn some math for the 90 minutes we were in class together. They smiled, they were kind to friends and other classmates, and seemed quite reasonable. And… and to have watched as the entire class, as some sort of organism, worked in tandem to suppress any chance of remediation. I don’t know. Maybe by thinking I should’ve done something, then and now, I’m merely an oppressor. I barely know them, and the large majority of their actions were more than positive. I… I don’t know… I’m still ambivalent, I guess, but I thought this merited serious pedagogical reflection, and posting.

Tuesday, April 19, 2016

Pedagogical Moment No. 5: How We Workshop


This past Monday, April, 4, Andrew (again, not his real name) said something similar about another person’s story, except that he said their piece was “a waste of time.” The class laughed, thinking that he was joking, or maybe because they were uncomfortable. Having written about last week’s class, having thought about the presumption of conduct and potential detriments to the normalization of workshop behavior, it is hard for me to give him the benefit of the doubt.

Because, regardless of your level of workshop experience, that is a rude thing to say, especially in a setting where the writer is vulnerable. In workshop, we have to trust that our classmates’ have our best interest in mind, that they will focus on what is and is not effective in our work, and that they will present it in a constructive way. For last week’s class, I also reflected on setting a precedent. In the interaction with Andrew I wrote about in the last post, I mentioned that he had given his feedback after everyone else had given theirs, and he did this again with this piece. The comment was harsh, much more harsh than what he had said about my work, and mostly importantly it didn't add to the discussion in a way that was specific or constructive. It was rude and unnecessary. And it made me mad. Instead of simply stating that he was being rude (which, honestly, I really wish I had done--as a student I am really getting tired of not call people out when they make me angry), a classmate and I said that we disagreed with him, and countered the content-specific suggestions he had made. But after class, my classmate who was being workshopped was hurt. The point of workshop is not to hurt people. 



I have been thinking a lot about my role as a student in this situation and my role as an instructor. I have been thinking about how I should address these situations, whether or not I should email my professor and tell her that the environment of the workshop makes me uncomfortable (because it has, it has seeped in and created a negative energy) or if I want to stick to the commitment of accountability that I entered the class with. I would like for the students to settle this among ourselves, to come up with a solution collectively. If things change, my assertion may, too. 

And while I want to exercise that student power within the classroom, I also have to say I am disappointed by my professor's inaction. Perhaps it is because she too believes in that student accountability. Maybe she doesn't want to interfere in how we talk to one another because we are graduate students. But even though student-professor dynamics change from undergraduate to graduate, to not address someone being mean and non-constructive to another student is to deny the real existence of a hierarchy within the classroom, as hooks says. At the end of the day, my professor is responsible to construct and conduct class, and to put our community guidelines into praxis. 


And this has lead me to think about what I would have done in the role of professor. Considering this at first--right in the moment it was happening, wondering what my professor was going to do--I was terrified of confronting that issue in my own classroom. But with hindsight I can see that something has to be done, and confronting hurtful language and not following class guidelines are not things that would necessarily isolate a student by speaking to them aloud, in the moment, in front of the rest of class. The world would not end if I had that intervention (which I think is why I am disappointed in my own professor's non-action). I think too that creating a community agreement by laying out the expectations for workshop participation is necessary from the beginning of the course, something I also noted was absent from my own. Even though I thought that, as a class, we had set a precedent for how workshops are generally conducted, there was nothing made explicit for how to conduct a workshop, and our experience was presumed. I think linking our mechanics of workshop to the reason we do what are doing speaks not only to creating an evocative and generative classroom environment like Bain says, and, as hooks writes: "[t]rust must be cultivated in the classroom if there is to be open dialectical exchange and positive dissent. It is helpful to explain to students from the start of a new class the importance of trust and the ways we link it to accountability" (87).

Thursday, April 14, 2016

Journal Entry #5

4/14/16 Journal Entry #5
            This week a pedagogical moment happened for me in conversation with my mom. This is actually a fairly common experience for me, as my mom often has questions about my program in sexuality studies and feminism. This specific conversation happened when my mom was visiting and after a few glasses of wine somehow the intersections of sex, race, class, gender, etc. came and my mom didn’t understand how anything like race and class could intersect with sex. However, the context of this learning moment for this reflection was not on the content necessarily. I began trying to explain how those intersections might work together and she continued to stop me at various parts and argue against what I was saying. I however did not see her rebuttals as relevant to what I was saying in many ways. After a fair amount of back and forth I realized it was because my mom didn’t understand most of the language I was using nor the examples. As soon as I realized this I backtracked some of my main points and I discussed them differently, using both plain language as well as very specific heterosexual examples in order to make my arguments make both sense as well as be personally relevant to experiences I know my mom could relate to. As soon as I did that she almost instantly seemed to understand what I was saying. She still disagreed to most of my points however her arguments made sense in the context of what I was saying at that point.
            After this conversation I was thinking a lot of about language use as well as access to language. I feel like people are so often coming from different perspectives of what words mean, whether that is because I word does have multiple meanings or maybe because one as a misinformed meaning of a word but at one point can be identified that two (or more people) in conversation are coming from different perspectives with their language use. In this situation the first clue I had that made me think that my mom had a different understanding of the language I was using was that her responses to it did not make sense. I feel as though this moment serves as a reminder to me to that I cannot presume others are operating from the same perspective of understanding. In thinking about a classroom this would require that I specifically discuss what the language I was using might mean as well as offer up space to discuss and debate terms. I think that a related although potentially different element to this would the access to certain language use and meanings. There are moments in my life that I realize my college education and/or the physical places that I have/am going to college in have giving me space to understand certain ideas and be exposed to the use of some language that is used to discuss issues of feminism, sexuality, gender, etc. So potentially even more than simply the understanding of language, someday I may be teaching classes in which the students attending have never before been exposed to what we are discussing. So this leads me to questions of how to think about address new language that is the basis for discussing ideas as well as how to do so in a way that is allowing students to critical engage with those lessons and not be reliant upon a banking method of teaching students about different uses of common language coming up in a classroom.