Wednesday, March 30, 2016

Pedagogical Moment 3: Guadalupe Elementary

     Today, as I reflect, it is March 27th. On assignment as a substitute teacher for SFUSD, March 15th, I was partway through a day of teaching (or managing) a set of 4th graders. That particular day I was working in tandem with a student teacher, who had only recently begun working with this class about a month prior. We'd gotten through to recess with their lead in most of the teacher's assigned instruction, myself intermittently leading but usually assisting. For this journal entry, I'll call the student teacher Andy.

     As we waited for the class to return and killed time with casual questions about each other's pedagogical interests, a parent knocked on the classroom’s door, which I promptly opened and invited them in. I'll call them Bernard, and they immediately asked if they could speak to the teacher. I informed them of the teacher's absence and my according role, and lead them to Andy thinking there might be some prior contact there. Bernard, instead, introduced themselves to Andy, and asked if they could put a lunch they'd brought into their child's backpack. Andy helped them locate it, and as they did, Bernard asked if they could speak for a moment about their child's time in the classroom.

     At Andy's agreement and interest, Bernard explained that their child was effectively being mistreated, so to speak, by the teacher. They had understood recent episodes of conflict between their child and classmates as ending with undue criticism of their child's actions and not enough criticism of the classmates’. Bernard felt the teacher had no sufficient reason for their severe actions toward their child. Listening, Andy was overtly sympathetic, and kindly responded saying Bernard could come in the following day to discuss the obviously significant issue with the teacher directly. Yet, at this, Bernard immediately stated such an attempt would be futile, and that in their opinion, the teacher was well beyond being affected positively by any such complaint. They seemed to imply, so to speak, that the teacher was intentionally critical and dismissive of their child's livelihood and education. Andy, of course, was flustered, yet they maintained a sympathetic response to the parent’s concerns and asked if they might bring up the issue to the teacher on behalf of Bernard. Bernard conceded, but added, derisively, that Andy's attempt would be useless. They thanked Andy for their time, asked a few questions about their history as a student teacher, thanked me, and left.

     I recalled this particular episode when reading Chapter 21 of bell hooks’ Teaching Critical Thinking, on self-esteem. She writes of realizing, in her experience, that as she “encountered highly intelligent students performing poorly because of their low self-esteem,” teachers can “promote healthy self-esteem in students by showing appropriate appreciation and awareness of their potential.” (125) In that classroom that today, I had already witnessed the work of Bernard’s child, and noted, before this episode even occurred, that they seemed rather excitable, yet clearly apt when directing their attention at the completion of the day’s coursework. Bernard’s revelations made me realize that there are many types of education occurring in a classroom, one of them being a social education: the students are engaged in a social activity within a social environment, and learning societal tropes and modes in that environment—learning, too, of the distinction made between acceptable and unacceptable social acts. If self-esteem, for Bernard’s child, is what is at stake, if a teacher is there at the front of a classroom not only to foster intellectual learning, so to speak, but also interpersonal learning, the profession becomes not only more complex, but more influential and imperative.

     hooks writes of “progressive pedagogy” (124), of pedagogy that facilitates the creation and utilization of an open space where “where working through problems, mutual respect, caring, and cooperation are the foundation of a meaningful education.” (126) This, for me, adds another requirement in my own education of education: I am not only to learn how to approach the instruction and material in a positive and inclusive way, but also, too, the very environment and social setting within which the various lessons and activities will take place. The value of educating myself in interpersonal psychology, of sociology, of various types of knowledge, seems equally paramount to learning philosophy itself. To approach not only my students but the social environments from which they will come—their parents and other activities/influences—and to attempt as much as is possible (or reasonable) to address those aspects of my students lives with awareness and responsibility… Bernard’s vocal dislike was a vivid reminder of this imperative. I would prefer not to have someone integrally connected to my student’s life feel unable to approach me with their concerns.

No comments:

Post a Comment