This past Thursday, I was one of three "veteran" tutors at my work (CARP) who were asked to participate in a meeting with the director of the Writing Center at the University of Illinois, Chicago. The director was visiting several university tutoring programs in the Bay Area, taking notes and dialoguing. Our program coordinator--the program's founder, my "main" boss, and the only non-student staff member--as well as our three student coordinators--my supervisors, as it were--were also in the meeting, and they explained our program to the visiting director. While the coordinators jobs were to explain the technicalities of how each of our services work--tutoring, workshops, and GWAR fellowships--our job as tutors was to talk about our experience in one-on-one sessions and our tutoring philosophies. It was in this self-reflexiveness of the meeting and afterward that my pedagogical moment occurred. Reflecting on the meeting the next day with my colleagues who were also in the meeting, I was reminded a great deal of bell hooks and Ken Bain's writing of what it takes to create praxis and a healthy learning community.
When the director from Chicago asked what my tutoring philosophy was, it kind of put me on the spot. I have a great love for my job, so I wasn't quite sure where to start. I told him that I would not say I have a philosophy, or that I had at least never thought of what I practice to be a philosophy. What I said was that I begin every tutoring session (each are one hour long) by asking what a student has come in for and what they would like to cover in the session. Upon reflection with my coworkers later, and with more reflection on my own now, I am able to better see and articulate how this action does come from theory. If a student comes in with a finished paper and asks only that I take a look at the grammar, but upon reading it I realize that the organization is incoherent or that the thesis statement is absent, we can set an agenda for the session and come to a mutual agreement about what we are going to get done. I will always make what they initially came in for a part of that agenda, even if it is not the top priority. This action becomes praxis because I get to enter into a learning agreement with that student for an hour--what do you want to take away from this? How can I assist you in your immediate concerns, while still being able to push and challenge you in writing in the hopes of empowering you as a learner? I do not simply tell them the answer, but try to create an environment for critical thinking, where we can help them develop skills they can use in the future. Having to tell someone how I approach a session made me reflective about my initial training at CARP and the skills I have developed and what I continue to test and adapt in the two years I have been working there. This reflexivity is a key component of praxis as well, as Ken Bain writes that this adaptability is a part of becoming more than a "routine expert" (67), because to ask students to challenge themselves means to challenge myself. Being able to speak with my coworkers about this, to reflect with them, was a continuation of that, a means of holding ourselves accountable and affirming our goals of creating a learning community in which everyone feels empowered (hooks, 21).
A brief note here: while my only role was to speak anecdotally about my time as a tutor, my coordinators' were expected to also give the visiting director the data on all of the ways in which we empirically measure our success. They had already gathered this data for the Department of Undergraduate Studies, so it was not generated only for this meeting. While this information on how many students we see each semester, how many professors request our in-class services, and how many students see improvements in their grades is useful, the necessity to collect the numbers was another reminder of the reality that we are residing within the corporate university. Our program has to produce mid-year and yearly reports on data such as this just to justify our existence to the Department of Undergraduate Studies. While we are practicing what we think of as intellectual empowerment and intangible progress, we are constantly asked to put this progress in a measurable form just to maintain our program. This reminds me a great deal of hooks' excerpt which talks about the place of "radical" practice within the confines of the university, and the compromise of participating in a capitalistic, dominator culture in order to exist at all (38). Upon further reflection, the idea that our program's prerogative is radical is baffling and the irony is not lost on me.
A sweet moment that I would like to end on was something my senior coordinator (CARP's founder) said to my supervisor and myself after he heard us reflecting on the meeting. My immediate supervisor relayed to the coordinator that the meeting was really empowering, and that it was inspiring for us to see everyone speaking so passionately about why they love their job and our collective goal. We were proud of one another was what we had said, to which my senior coordinator responded, "how proud you feel now is how you all make me feel every day." Hearing that I am appreciated at my job, that my individual work and our teamwork is valued, made me feel like a part of a learning community.
No comments:
Post a Comment